AI in Social Media: The Good, The Bad, and the Cringey

Editorial: LinkedIn's Identity Crisis - When Professional Networking Met Performance Art

In partnership with

Happy Wednesday, social media pros!

If you’ve been keeping up with social media this week, you’ve likely seen all the news about DeepSeek. Admittedly, I don’t really know a whole lot about the “back end” of all these different AI platforms. I know what I can do with them, but I don’t know much about how they operate and what separates the platforms from one another.

That’s a topic for some other AI newsletter, not The Social Media Journal.

But with all the attention on AI this week, I figured I’d talk about using AI for social media content creation. It’s a subject that really grinds my gears. I hate seeing brands use captions that were clearly written by AI. It’s so obvious it hurts.

So let’s talk strategy about what to avoid and how to effectively use AI for your social media content creation.

Looking for unbiased, fact-based news? Join 1440 today.

Upgrade your news intake with 1440! Dive into a daily newsletter trusted by millions for its comprehensive, 5-minute snapshot of the world's happenings. We navigate through over 100 sources to bring you fact-based news on politics, business, and culture—minus the bias and absolutely free.

AI in Social Media: Beyond the Basic Bot Blunders

Let's talk about the elephant in the room: AI-generated social media content. You know the type - those posts that read like they were written by a cheerful robot who learned English from a marketing textbook circa 1995. "Embrace the magic of Monday with this stunning sunset! 🌅 #blessed #mondaymotivation #inspiration #success #grindneverstops"

Yikes.

If you're using AI to spit out generic captions that sound like they came from a fortune cookie factory, we need to have a chat. Your followers can spot these a mile away, and let's be honest - they're probably rolling their eyes so hard.

But here's the thing: AI isn't the villain in this story. It's more like a misunderstood genius that we're still figuring out how to work with. Think of it as that brilliant intern who needs clear direction and a bit of human supervision to truly shine.

The Good, The Bad, and The Cringey

Let's start with the painful stuff. Basic AI-generated captions often fall into these classic traps:

  • The Hashtag Hurricane: When your post ends with more hashtags than actual content, you're doing it wrong. Your feed isn't a hashtag repository.

  • The Emoji Bookends: "🌟 Just launched our new product! Check it out! 🚀" If your caption starts and ends with emojis, we see you (or rather, we see your AI). It’s a dead giveaway every time.

  • The Generic Cheerleader: "Rise and grind!" "Chase your dreams!" We get it, AI, you've memorized every motivational poster ever made.

  • The Emotion Impostor: AI trying to convey genuine emotion often sounds like an alien attempting to describe human feelings after watching exactly one Hallmark movie.

But before you swear off AI completely, let's talk about where this technology actually shines.

The Smart Way to Use AI in Social Media

Here's where AI becomes your secret weapon rather than your social media nemesis:

Content Ideation and Brainstorming

Instead of asking AI to write your captions, use it as your brainstorming buddy. Try prompts like "What are some unique angles to discuss sustainable fashion?" or "Generate controversial opinions about remote work." Then take those raw ideas and add your human perspective and personality.

Content Calendar Planning

AI excels at identifying patterns and suggesting content rhythms. Use it to plan your content calendar, spot gaps in your strategy, and suggest themed content series that align with your brand voice.

Analytics and Trend Analysis

Let AI crunch the numbers and spot trends in your engagement data. It can help you understand what content resonates best with your audience and when to post for maximum impact.

First Draft Framework

Think of AI as your first-draft machine. Let it create the skeleton of your posts, then go in and inject your personality, industry expertise, and authentic voice. It's like having a super-efficient assistant who gives you a running start.

The Secret Sauce: Human + AI Collaboration

The magic happens when you find the sweet spot between AI efficiency and human creativity. Here's your game plan:

  1. Use AI for the heavy lifting: research, data analysis, and initial ideation

  2. Add your unique perspective and industry expertise

  3. Inject personality and authentic experiences

  4. Edit ruthlessly - if it sounds like it could have been written by anyone (or anything), it needs more of YOUR voice

Remember, your followers aren't connecting with your brand because they want to read AI-generated platitudes. They're there for your unique perspective, your real experiences, and your authentic voice.

Pro Tips for Next-Level AI Usage

  • Create custom prompt templates that include your brand voice guidelines

  • Keep a swipe file of your best-performing organic content to help train AI on your style

  • Use AI to identify content gaps and opportunities in your niche

  • Leverage AI for A/B testing headlines and hooks, then apply what you learn

  • Build a library of your unique stories and experiences to weave into AI-generated frameworks

The Bottom Line

AI in social media is like having a superpower - but with great power comes great responsibility. The key is using AI as a tool to amplify your authenticity, not replace it.

Your social media presence should be as unique as your fingerprint, not as generic as a template. Use AI to handle the grunt work, but let your personality shine through in the final product. After all, in a world of algorithms, authenticity is your ultimate differentiator.

Do you use AI to aid your social media content creation?

Login or Subscribe to participate in polls.

Learn What Fortune 500 Marketers Know

  • Marketing strategies from industry leaders like the NBA, Liquid Death & Oatly.

  • Behind-the-scenes stories of campaigns that crushed it.

  • Actionable tips to boost your results today.

This Week’s Social Media Meme

LinkedIn's Identity Crisis: When Professional Networking Met Performance Art

Every day, I open LinkedIn and prepare myself for today's episode of "Things That Definitely Happened in the Professional World." There it is – another post about how someone hired the job candidate who showed up late (plot twist: they were helping an elderly person cross the street!), or the CEO who learned a profound life lesson from their five-year-old about market dynamics during breakfast.

Remember when LinkedIn was just a digital rolodex where we'd occasionally congratulate someone on their work anniversary? Those were simpler times. Now it's transformed into a theatrical production where every minor workplace interaction gets reimagined as a TED talk, and every coffee run becomes a parable about perseverance.

The evolution has been fascinating to watch. What started as a platform for job hunting and professional networking has morphed into a curious hybrid of motivational speaking conference and high school reunion. Your former colleague isn't just announcing a new job – they're sharing a 17-part saga about their "journey," complete with more life lessons than a fortune cookie factory.

But here's the thing – beneath all the cringe-worthy storytelling and humble-brag Olympics, something interesting is happening. LinkedIn's transformation reflects a broader shift in how we view professionalism. The starched-collar, all-business persona is giving way to something messier but potentially more authentic. Well, "authentic" in air quotes, because let's be honest – nobody's sharing their real workplace disasters or that time they accidentally replied-all to the entire company.

The platform has become a stage where we perform our professional best selves, complete with carefully curated vulnerability. "I failed," the posts begin, before inevitably pivoting to an inspiring triumph that would make Rocky Balboa blush. It's like watching a corporate version of reality TV – we all know it's heavily edited, but we can't stop scrolling.

Critics argue (and I tend to be one of those) that LinkedIn is losing its way, becoming Facebook with a tie on. They're not entirely wrong. Between the AI-generated inspirational quotes floating over sunset backgrounds and the "agree?" poll posts that are about as deep as a puddle, there's plenty to roll your eyes at.

Yet there's something oddly compelling about this new LinkedIn. In an era where the lines between personal and professional life are increasingly blurry (thanks, remote work!), maybe it makes sense that our professional networking platform reflects that change. We're not just our job titles anymore – we're complex humans who happen to work for a living.

Still, I can't help but chuckle at how predictable the content has become. If you created a LinkedIn Post Bingo card with squares for "I took a chance on an unconventional candidate," "The real ROI is the friends we made along the way," and "Who else agrees that kindness matters in business?" you'd win before your morning meeting.

So yes, LinkedIn has become a bit of a circus. But maybe that's not entirely bad. In between the performative posts and professional peacocking, real connections are still being made, jobs are still being found, and occasionally – very occasionally – someone shares something genuinely insightful.

Looking For More?

Get a FREE Social Media Audit!

Wondering how you’re doing on the social media front? We’ve got you covered! We’re offering you a FREE social media audit of all your profiles!

We’ll take a deep dive into your accounts, looking at your profile setup and how your posts are doing. We’ll then provide you expert feedback and recommendations to help take your accounts to the next level.

Interested? Get in touch today!

Our Favorite Software

This newsletter is distributed through beehiiv, the BEST platform for newsletters and email marketing. If you write a newsletter, you’ll want to try it!

We use Vista Social for managing all of our clients’ social media accounts. We love it! It has everything you need and you can’t beat the price!

Newsletter Brought to You By Harden Digital and Design

Reply

or to participate.